Greater Orange HEADLINES in the News
Follow Greater Orange on TWITTER
TOP LOCAL ORANGE COUNTY NEWS STORIES on the WEB
Wednesday, July 26, 2017
Just days from Christensen's retirement...
Board's search for new OUSD Superintendent continues with a company familiar with controversy
The OUSD Board does not yet have an Interim Superintendent in place as the search for a new Orange Unified School District Superintendent continues, despite having a four month notification of his retirement by current OUSD Superintendent Michael Christensen. Christensen's retirement announcement was made public four months ago on May 1, 2017, then setting August 1st as his retirement date.
For more information Click on RETIREMENT
This Thursday July 27th, just five working days before Christensen's now "effective retirement date" of August 2nd, and the OUSD Board of Education will just be getting "possible names" and discussing the process for hiring an Interim Superintendent according to the July 27th Agenda for Information Item 13 A (page 17). The name for the position of Interim Superintendent will be provided by McPherson & Jacobson, the school executive recruitment firm chosen to led the search for a new OUSD Superintendent.
According to on-line documents, McPherson & Jacobson does not "recruit" for Interim Superintendents. The firm uses an internal list of candidates who will provide interim superintendent services. The the firm's normal process for Interim Superintendent placement, according to a McPherson & Jacobson document (see link below), is that the firm provides just one candidate name at a time .
This "one name" process that McPherson & Jacobson uses has led to past controversies (see "Caveat Emptor" section below). If the one-name process is indeed the process McPherson & Jacobson uses with OUSD, that is effectively having the McPherson & Jacobson CEO Dr. Thomas Jacobson "placing" the Interim Superintendent position without the promised Phase II community outreach stakeholders-which theoretically gives the firm an understanding of how to match candidates to the district (see "Caveat Emptor" section below).
For more information Click on Sample report below
In the past, those Interim Superintendent's provided by McPherson & Jacobson have had an inside track to the superintendent's position when McPherson & Jacobson finally does post the position. The McPherson & Jacobson position postings are promised to include criteria that is based on the district's "stakeholder" input in the company's promised Phase II of its recruitment.
The July 27th OUSD Agenda Item calls for a teleconferencing call from Dr. Thomas Jacobson the owner of the Omaha, Nebraska based McPherson & Jacobson a school executive recruitment firm chosen to find a new OUSD superintendent. Dr. Thomas Jacobson is personally leading the search for OUSD.
For more information Click on
Dr. Thomas Jacobson founded the firm in 1991 with his then university department chair Dan McPherson. Thomas then bought out his partner in Dan McPherson 1994. The small firm has placed about 500 superintendents using a decentralized consulting model with almost 100 part-time independent consultants spread nationwide in 38 states. The McPherson & Jacobson consultants basically moonlight for the firm which has led to some controversy when a consultant (many school principals and superintendents themselves) allegedly worked during their regular jobs moonlighting for McPherson & Jacobson.
In 2014, the California School Boards Association "partnered" with McPherson & Jacobson as the association's "executive search team's partner".
At the time of the CSBA partnership, McPherson & Jacobson boasted that 80% of its hires were still in their positions 6 years later. Of the 20% that were not, some districts had significant problems with McPherson & Jacobson superintendents they claim were not properly vetted by McPherson & Jacobson. From
Pleasanton, California to
Las Vegas, Nevada
to Little Rock Arkansas
and , the firm has been in the middle
of some major controversies over its
recommended recruits. New London, Connecticut
"Caveat Emptor" and McPherson & Jacobson
While McPherson & Jacobson advertises since 1991 it has placed almost 500 superintendents, major controversies over its recruits are industry legends. When these problems occur, McPherson & Jacobson (despite its Phase III promise of checking and vetting candidates) almost universally has stated it is the state government's responsibility to vet the credentials of the recruits. In addition, there is that McPherson & Jacobson two year guarantee. However, as these recent cases below illustrate- when a superintendent recruit is fired, damage to the school district has already been done.
Despite the McPherson & Jacobson "guarantee" of a free new search ( actually only charging "costs" to a district) to replace a Superintendent if a hired Superintendent "left" before 2 years, this year the Pleasanton Unified School Board in Pleasanton.
joined other districts that decided not to take McPherson & Jacobson up on
their "two year guarantee". The Pleasanton Board fired McPherson & Jacobson
recruit Superintendent Rick Rubino after 6 months for an "undisclosed"
personal matter. That firing cost the Pleasanton Board over
$264,000 contractually to fire Rubino. California
The Pleasanton Board was then forced to apologize to the community. The Pleasanton Weekly reported (see link below):
Trustee Jamie Hintzke said she worked closely with the search firm's consultants as board president at the time, referencing unhappiness and "their unprofessionalism” without going into specifics.
“It was completely frustrating,” Hintzke said of her dealings with the consultants. “I don't think it's worth having them make good on their contract.”
For more information, click on:
In 2014, the New London School District in New London, Connecticut rescinded the job offer for their superintendent position to Terrence P. Carter. Mr. Carter was recruited by McPherson & Jacobson for the
position. After the school board offered
Carter the position, and he accepted, local investigative reporters discovered
and reported that Carter's doctorate came from an on-line "diploma mill"
- Lexington University. That unaccredited "school" advertised a doctorate
degree for $225 as "Order Now,
Graduate Today!" . In addition, they reported that Carter had filed two
bankruptcies and that Carter's résumé included a degree from the New London
School District University of Chicago,
which the University reported Carter did not have, and a doctorate degree from -which Stanford disclosed Carter
had never attended. Stanford University
In 2015, the
demanded that McPherson &
Jacobson refund the money the district paid to the firm for
the search. That same year, Mr. Carter
sued the New London District for rescinding the employment offer. New London School District
For more information, click on
got its first, but not last McPherson & Jacobson controversy with a McPherson & Jacobson recommended Interim Superintendent Dr. Walter Milton. A community outcry eventually led to Dr.
Milton not being hired as the new Little Rock Superintendent. Little Rock Arkansas School District
Then, between 2015 and 2017,
had another McPherson & Jacobson Superintendent
controversy blow up over alleged doctoral plagiarism by a McPherson & Jacobson
screened and provided Interim Superintendent Dexter Suggs. That multi-year scandal
led to Suggs doctorate being withdrawn and Suggs severance pay with the state
of Little Rock Arkansas School District ending.
The state government at one point also
took over the beleaguered school district. Arkansas
- Suggs selected as Little Rock Superintendent
- Dexter Suggs
- Suggs resigns
- Suggs doctorate rescinded
For a sampling of other McPherson & Jacobson controversies click on:
- Pittsburg , Kansas 2017 McPherson & Jacobson consultant exposed by High School journalists
Las Vegas UnifiedPricing Controversy 2013
McPherson & Jacobson OUSD Interim Superintendent
OUSD's long and winding road to a new Superintendent
The Orange Unified quest for a new Superintendent did begin shortly after the retirement announcement of the popular Superintendent Michael Christensen. An internal email went out to OUSD leadership personal starting an internal search for a replacement Superintendent would be conducted. Numerous accounts from within OUSD had that very compressed application process producing two candidates. Eventually one withdrew from consideration.
Reportedly, at the Saturday June 10, 2017 Special Meeting of the OUSD Board of Education for Consideration of an Appointment of a Superintendent, the remaining candidate was not accepted-thus leading to the OUSD Board to vote 4-3 to go forward in hiring a firm to help recruit a new superintendent.
For more information click on June 10 Minutes
Twelve days later, at the June 22nd Regular Board Meeting, the OUSD Board heard presentations from three executive search firms. The June 22nd Agenda's Closed Session had an item for "Consideration of an Interim Superintendent", but no vote was reported out of the Closed Session and no Interim Superintendent was appointed.
Nine days later, a Special Meeting was held on Saturday July 1st to select one of the three firms to recruit a superintendent. At that meeting the Board voted to selected McPherson & Jacobson.
Now on July 27th, twenty-six days later and just five working days before the retirement of Superintendent Michael Christensen, Item 13 A has McPherson & Jacobson owner Dr. Thomas Jacobson presenting to the OUSD Board meeting by telephone from
the "selection process" for an Interim OUSD Superintendent. Omaha
However more than that, Dr. Jacobson will provide "names and rankings of potential candidates" for the Interim OUSD Superintendent position. As in other McPherson & Jacobson recruitment cases, the inevitable Interim Superintendent will have an inside track to the permanent position.
The names and rankings of Interim Superintendent candidates are being provided before McPherson & Jacobson website has opened the application process for the OUSD Superintendent position. As of the posting of this story, the McPherson & Jacobson website has the OUSD superintendent position listed as "More information coming" .
Click on McPherson & Jacobson postings
Currently McPherson & Jacobson has only one
school district application information of the three (including OUSD) it is currently recruiting. California
click on Recruitment Information
The July 27th OUSD Agenda also states an OUSD Special Board Meeting will be held at a later date for the OUSD Board to interview "potential candidates". Currently an OUSD Special Meeting is scheduled for Thursday August 10th.
Executive Director of Secondary Education leaves for Brea- O Unified
Another top OUSD Administrator leaves
The third top OUSD Administrator within the last 4 months will be leaving OUSD. OUSD Secondary Executive Director Kerrie Torres will be leaving OUSD to become Brea-Orlinda Unified's new Assistant Superintendent of Administrative Services. Ms. Torres has been OUSD's Secondary Director for 4 years.
OUSD sources state that more top administrators are looking for new homes in the wake of Christensen's departure from the district. The huge administrative upheavals- the Superintendent, the Assistant Superintendent Business Services and now the Executive Director of Secondary Education , come as OUSD works to manage its rebuilding of its four comprehensive high schools with the Measure S Bond that the Christensen Management Team was able to pass.
For more information click on
Inside the June 27, 2017 Agenda
The Orange Unified School Board will meet on Thursday June 27, 2017 in a regular session.
The Agenda also includes:
- Action Item 12 A - Contract for Teachers and Leadership Team-Agenda page 16
- Information Item 13 B- Measure S Financial Update- Agenda page 18
NEXT OUSD BOARD MEETING July 27, 2017
Next OUSD Board Meeting -OUSD BOARD ROOM
CLOSED SESSION- 6:00 pm
OUSD Regular Session: 7:00 pm
: OUSD AGENDA AGENDA-CLICK ON
For more information call the OUSD Superintendent’s office at 714-628-4040
For budgeting questions call Business Services at 714-628-4015
ARCHIVAL Information and direct news can be found at:
are independent news services of /O/N/N/
Orange Net News
Follow us on TWITTER